Home » Beauty » The L’Eau-down on Colognes

The L’Eau-down on Colognes

See what I did there? With the title? The “l’eau-down”? Get it? Let me just dodge the huge tumbleweed that’s rolling towards me and then I’ll get on with the post.

Colognes! What does that word make you think of? Beautiful orange and lemon groves and crumbling old villas next to the mediterranean? Or a middle-aged Italian man with greased back hair trying to proposition you in the middle of a Milanese street? For me, it used to be the latter, but I am gradually coming around to the joys of a light, fresh cologne.


A cologne, for those of you who aren’t sure, is a perfume with a very low percentage of actual perfume oil or essential oil – it’s lighter, less intense and it doesn’t last for anywhere near as long as an eau de toilette or parfum. It’s usually far cheaper per ml than the more concentrated versions of the scent and usually comes in larger quantities so that you can spritz or splash away to your heart’s content.

It’s not only the concentration of the scent that’s different to your regular perfume, though; the top notes are typically fresh and citrussy (Bergamot, Neroli, Lemon, Mandarin, Lime, Grapefruit), often offset by Lavender, Thyme and Petitgrain. The classic version would have to be the Original Eau de Cologne, 4711, but there are hundreds available now, all of them different, lots of them extraordinarily beautiful. I’ve gathered together some of my favourites – a few of them aren’t colognes, strictly speaking, and a couple aren’t labelled as one but should be!

I think that there’s a degree of snobbery towards colognes, but I’d point you firmly in the direction of Tom Ford’s Neroli Portofino: all of the notes of a classic cologne, and has even been relaunched in a “splash” bottle. So there – colognes are most definitely stylish!

From left to right:

1) Roger & Gallet Jean Marie Farina Cologne. This has oranges and lemons and a lovely woody base. Classic, but limited edition for R&G’s 150th Year Anniversary. £30.60 at Escentual.com

2) Acqua di Parma Fico di Amalfi. I reviewed this recently (read the Fico di Amalfi Review here) and I absolutely adore the “fig” twist on the traditional cologne scent. It’s stunning. Out of stock at John Lewis, but Escentual.com have it with free delivery. Most definitely unisex, this one – read the review!

3) 4711 – the original eau de cologne. And it really is. This holds a place in many a heart – it’s pretty old-school, but massively popular! £17 from Escentual.com Again, definitely unisex.

4) l’Occitane’s Eau Captivante comes in a HUGE “Art Deco” glass bottle. The scent is beautiful – Bergamot, Lime, Mint and Basil – very zesty and fresh. Though it’s unisex, I can imagine that this would be very popular with men. It has that “shower fresh” feel that’s light and sexy. l’Occitane do scent so well – it’s usually the florals that I’m drawn to (their Peony is immense!) but the colognes are spot on. Clean and crisp. Find them here:  Eau Captivante

5) Tom Ford’s Neroli Portofino is, as I mentioned, very close to the classic cologne scent, but as with anything Tom Ford, there’s a little bit of magic thrown in. Don’t know what it is – something a bit deeper and darker – but this manages to be sporty, sexy, exotic and heady all at the same time. This is a fresher version of the original Neroli Portofino scent and it comes in a much, much larger bottle with a “splash” top rather than a spray. Again, firmly unisex. £85 from Selfridges.com

6) Jo Malone’s Lime, Basil & Mandarin Cologne is one of the all-time bestsellers. And for good reason. It has some of those citrussy cologne top-notes, but then a really modern and unusual twist. There’s this light, soapy sweetness that’s (I think) quite feminine, but I can see how this would also be such a popular male choice. Jo Malone’s fragrances last so long that I’m not sure they can be compared with some of the lighter “splashes” and “spritzers” – you can also layer different scents to create a bespoke fragrance. From £38, Selfridges.com

a model beauty and style blog

7) Agua de Colonia Concentrada – reviewed here recently. (Told you I had a cologne fixation!) Spicy, herby, fruity. Cologne with added fire, would be the best description of this one! It comes in a bright yellow box (you can just see it peeping out in the photograph above) and the bottle reminds me of some kind of exotic tequila or rum bottle. Nice! Find this one on Carter and Bond.

That’s all of my tried-and-testeds, but there’s a little extra mention. The Verde d’Arancia from Monotheme’s Library of Citruses (Il Libro Degli Agrumi) is just the purest orange scent in a bottle. (Far left in photograph above.) If you puréed an orange, peel, pith and all, and jammed it into a pot, it would smell like this. It’s happy, summery and vibrant. It’s not a cologne, but whilst we’re on citrus notes, I thought I’d drop this one in! £22.50 from the recently launched M&S Beauty Paradise!

How do you feel about colognes now? Tempted? To finish this marathon post, I just wanted to tell you a few ways that you can use cologne – feel free to add your own suggestions. Firstly, they make quite wonderful emergency room sprays. There’s something about the fruity, sharp notes that make musty rooms smell fresh again. Ditto for laundry water or for spritzing bed linen and towels. You can add a splash of cologne to bathwater for a light scent that doesn’t leave any oily residue, and you can use the cologne as a body splash when the weather’s hot.

Signing off now, as I may go insane if I write the word Cologne one more time! For more fragrance reviews, click here!

© 2016 A Model Recommends®: all opinions are my own and any sponsored or paid posts will always be very clearly marked. I accept press samples and receive product and services to review as part of my job. Outward links to retailers will usually be affiliate links. Please see here for full "about" section and disclaimer.  A Model Recommends and Ruth Crilly are registered trademarks.

43 comments

  1. I dont think I will ever abandon my summery eau de toilette for cologne but these retro looking bottles are works of art.If I had an empty one I would fill it with my homemade rosewater and keep it for ever!

  2. They’re always a bit strong for me, but nice selection there xx

  3. To say I’m obsessed with Neroli Portofino would be an understatement! I drown myself in it whenever I’m in the department store and I will buy it this year if I have to go hungry!

    Great post

  4. Whats your favorite perfume ?

  5. Thank you for such a lovely post Ruth! Have you tried Jo Malone’s Wild Fig and Cassis? I absolutely adore it!x

  6. I’m a long term fan of 4711 and I think my love of Chanel No19 is because it has cologne leanings or heritage. I’m intrigued by the Tom Ford but not sure I could swallow that price tag for a cologne – is it more long lasting?

    • It’s less long lasting than the Private Blend Perfume version, but then that one is well over £100 for a much smaller amount, so it’s swings and roundabouts! x

  7. I actually never knew the difference between an eau de toilette and cologne–so your post was very informative for me. I’m really wanting to try the Jo Malone one now. Would you believe, I’ve never tried ANY of her scents?!

  8. I do like the loccitane one, and the bottle is beautiful, I am lucky enough to have a loccitane store near me :-) so this will be finding its way into my bedroom soon lol!
    I must admit though i think colognes are generally thought of as being abit old fashioned, so your post was quite interesting.

  9. 4711 brings back so many memories. I thought it the height of sophistication when I started university. You nailed it with “old school” and in many hearts. It was also a political statement as our school went coed just the year before – the unisex thing was quite “daring.” :)
    Thanks for the sum up, Ruth. I’m trying to find a new scent that will be “me.”

  10. I am from Cologne, where they make 4711. It is hugely popular with the tourists, of course, but most Colonians would not wear it. It is very much considered an old-lady smell here, I’m afraid. I don’t dislike the scent personally, but I would never spray it on me because the scent is instantly recognisable.

    • Oh, someone else from Cologne just wrote what I was about to say, haha!
      It’s true, only elder ladies would wear it here. The House of 4711 promoted some new scents a while ago, maybe something to be checked out by the Eau de Cologne hardcore-fans…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

Scroll To Top